Beach Fossils - Clash the Truth Review

I have a strange relationship with Beach Fossils. When they first appeared back in 2009, they were one of only a handful of bands involved in a very specific style of summer-infused indie rock. Jump forward to 2013 and a quick search will pull up any number of bands doing similar, and better, things. While I consider Beach Fossils to be an excellent band, their only release that has ever really held my attention was their 2011 EP What A Pleasure.
What A Pleasure brought about a noticeable shift in Beach Fossils’ sound. Allowing John Peña (bass, now Heavenly Beat) and Zachary Cole-Smith (guitar, now DIIV) to influence the songwriting, and pairing up with Jack Tatum (Wild Nothing) for ‘Out in the Way’, introduced an urgent pulsing quality to their previously nonchalant style.
Since then, both Peña and ZCS have departed from the band to focus on their own projects. This has left Dustin Payseur in a difficult position and has made it glaringly obvious as to how much he depended upon the input from those past members. Stating that this would be ‘a harder and faster album’, I was under the impression that he would be following the direction that DIIV took in the hopes of jumping onto some of their success. Instead Clash the Truth presents a more direct sound than before, crafted around a forced songwriting style.
Clash the Truth isn’t a bad album and Payseur does know how to write good songs, my main problem with it is the mostly lacklustre first half. Opening track ‘Clash the Truth’ is one of the low points of the album, featuring unimaginative guitars entwined with a particularly embarrassing spoken word section. Cutting the three unnecessary instrumental tracks (not saying that all instrumental tracks are unnecessary, just that the three on Clash the Truth serve no purpose acting purely as padding) and removing the painfully dull ‘Sleep Apnea’ would have made Clash the Truth a far stronger record, tightening its focus.
New single ‘Careless’ and the meaner and more aggressive version of the previously released ‘Shallow’ are perfect examples of where Dustin gets it right. Hard and fast tracks, filled with an abundance of energy and buzzing guitars, these make up some of the best songs on the album showcasing Payseur’s post-punk influences.
I don’t mean to seem too negative, again, this isn’t a ‘bad’ album and there are enough enjoyable tracks that will ensure I return periodically, it’s just that my expectations had been set to such a height. Clash the Truth shows that while Payseur has plenty of good ideas, if his songs are to be truly great he needs to learn how to transform these ideas on his own without relying on the help of others.
Listen to album highlight and closing track ‘Crashed Out’ above. Purchase Clash the Truth here.